WA live exporter reassesses investment amid sheep trade uncertainty

Fiona Myers, August 10, 2018

Harmony managing director Stephen Meerwald.

WESTERN Australian-based live exporter Harmony Agriculture and Food will send two loads of cattle this month, but has put its sheep export program on hold.

Harmony managing director Stephen Meerwald this week conceded he had concerns about the shipping of sheep after receiving a letter from Animals Australia.

The letter included a 650-page document on meteorological data and information on the injunction process AA would follow if the company was implicated in any animal welfare situations.

That letter was sent not only to Mr Meerwald, but to all of the company’s directors including the company’s chairman in China, and “it went to him directly”, Mr Meerwald said.

The company was to start sourcing sheep for a 13,000-head shipment to Oman which was due next week, but have pulled out of this due to concerns it may end up in a similar situation to Emmanuel Exports, where sheep have been held in quarantine since mid-June.

“We know we could deliver the sheep on our ship to Oman, and we would do it well,” Mr Meerwald said.

“We could manage the outcomes to the best of our ability but not to zero risk as there is no such thing as zero risk when you put them on the boat.”

Harmony unwilling to wear costs of shipment interruptions

Harmony is not prepared to wear the $40,000 potential cost per day of a ship in port, nor the costs of keeping sheep in quarantine, if a shipment is stopped.

The company’s board is also reassessing its plans for its new property at Woottating about one hour north-east of Perth, which was bought in September to be a pre-export quarantine facility to feed into Fremantle.

“I’m not sure that is still exactly part of our plan and it might be, but we are not prepared to make that decision until we have a bit more clarity,” Mr Meerwald said.

The two cattle shipments will go ahead and are due to leave in the next week, including one ship to China, which gets into port today and loads next week. The other will berth in Darwin on August 10 and is destined for Indonesia.

Mr Meerwald said the trade to China had been slower than the company had anticipated and hence the decision to service other markets.

“There’s a whole range of other activity we are doing as a consequence of having a range of markets and not having a dependence on one particular trade,” he said.

Harmony has shipped 12,600 cattle to China since the end of last year.

“The cattle are predominately 600kg, 100-day plus grainfed Angus cattle,” Mr Meerwald said.

“We do know it can be done, we do know these cattle travel really well, we do know they kill out really well.

“We’ve seen them hanging in the chiller through the viewing window … we’ve seen the quality and colour of the meat and we’ve seen the quality and colour of the fat.

“We know we can do that, we know that that product has a market in China but it’s a new product.

“Not only are we shipping in a way no-one’s shipped before with an animal that no-one shipped before, on routes no-one has shipped before other than little dairy heifers, but we are going into a market and putting Australian-produced animals into the Chinese market potentially as a fresh product.

“That hasn’t happened before.”


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your comment will not appear until it has been moderated.
Contributions that contravene our Comments Policy will not be published.


  1. Tom Casey, August 12, 2018

    I wonder if Animals Australia is responsible for compensation for the bankrupt businesses to come out of this shambles on all sides — as the Greens and Julia Gillard were for the Indonesian crisis that broke mainly family properties in the Top End?

  2. Jane Speechley, August 10, 2018

    I think it might be because Animals Australia is right, Graham. Clearly, these companies are recognising that the claimed risks are actually very real, and that an injunction would most likely be successful.

    Remember, court action would bring about that which the live export industry fears the most: independent and public scrutiny of their businesses, their practises and the conditions they keep animals in. It’s no wonder they are running scared.

  3. Grahamn Kindred, August 10, 2018

    The vocal minority looks as though they are winning this story. They should be challenged and closed down.

  4. Graham Kindred, August 10, 2018

    Why does everyone have to give in to Animals Australia? It looks like they have everyone running scared. They should be shut down.

Get Sheep Central's news headlines emailed to you -