Lamb Production

Sheep producer questions Agriculture Victoria staff changes

Terry Sim, November 13, 2019

Pigeon Ponds sheep producer Tim Leeming. Picture – MLA.

LEADING Victorian sheep meat industry representative Tim Leeming has called for wide producer consultation on proposed changes at Agriculture Victoria centres.

Agriculture Victoria has backed away from reports of potential staff cuts, claiming it is conducting an internal review of research that doesn’t attract co-investment.

AV has said any changes will be made in full consultation with its staff and the Community and Public Sector Union; however, Sheep Central believes some staff had been told their positions were at risk or under review because they had attracted insufficient co-investment.

Earlier this week, The Weekly Times reported that the Victorian Government was set to cut 49 jobs from Agriculture Victoria’s research centres. Affected sites included soil scientist at AgriBio Bundoora, five people at Hamilton, research, technical, salinity and groundwater staff at the Macleod office and possibly positions at Ellinbank’s centre for dairy research, the paper reported.

Minister for Agriculture Jaclyn Symes has declined to issue a statement on the issue. Sheep Central has been told that no research staff have been told their positions were redundant, but that talks had been held with some Agriculture Victoria team members potentially affected by proposed changes.

However, Mr Leeming, the former chairman of the Southern Australia Livestock Research Council’s western Victorian regional committee, believed earlier this week that some Agriculture Victoria research staff had been “given their marching orders”, potentially impacting future research at the AV Hamilton centre.

Funding allocation questions need answers – Leeming

Agriculture Victoria’s Hamilton Centre

The Pigeon Ponds prime lamb and maternal seedstock producer also questioned the State Government’s RDAE expenditure on agricultural commodities in recent years.

“There needs to be some questions asked about the imbalance in spend between commodities and who is actually pulling the strings in relation to allocations of investment and co-investment across dairy, grain and meat research.”

He believed Ms Symes should be invited to tour Agriculture Victoria’s Hamilton Centre to look at the facilities and talk with producers.

Mr Leeming said sheep meat and wool producers should consult heavily with the Victorian Government on the direction of investment and co-investment into research, development, adoption and extension in red meat, wool, sheep and beef areas.

“I worry as do many producers across the state that there has been a deliberate dilution of resources into our industry.

“How we structure state, levy and private moneys into the future is vital for viability of our products,” he said.

Co-investment review underway

An Agriculture Victoria spokesperson said the division was “listening to farming businesses, reviewing research that doesn’t attract co-investment from industry, while we grow research and innovation initiatives that have strong industry support – to boost our farming sector and create jobs.”

“Agriculture Victoria is considering adjustments to its operations so it can best respond to emerging science and technology innovation and deliver world-leading research for Victoria’s agriculture sector.

“Any changes will be made in full consultation with our staff and the Community and Public Sector Union,” the spokesperson said.

“Victoria is leading the nation in agriculture research and it’s important that we focus our efforts on what our farmers need to thrive for decades to come.

“Our research projects are designed, developed and delivered with industry, producing timely, relevant and accessible innovation for Victorian agriculture.”

Red meat research cuts short-sighted – Leeming

Mr Leeming said as a producer and a SALRC regional committee member he believed any Agriculture Victoria cuts were short-sighted.

“We’ve been so fortunate in Victoria to have that independence of research – with private government researchers working together and sharing.

“I think it is very short-sighted in that sheep and red meat has been the biggest agricultural earner for Victoria in recent times and probably will be for the near future,” he said.

“If you think of a pasture analogy, you are cutting heaps of hay or pasture off a paddock but you are not replacing the nutrient that you are taking off – it’s as simple as that.

“You can’t just take with one hand and not give back,” Mr Leeming said.

“The public purse is so much better off with red meat and where it is at the moment and to lose the independence in research and development is very naïve and extremely short-sighted.”

SALRC was established by Meat & Livestock Australia to encourage southern Australia’s grassroots cattle and sheep producers to drive the future direction of levy-payer funded research and development for their area. Mr Leeming said co-investment in research and the levy-funded bodies like Meat & Livestock Australia and Australian Wool Innovation also had to recognise the importance of localising research and development.

“We know that south-west Victorian has the highest concentration of production of red meat in Australia and the AV Hamilton centre, formerly known as Hamilton PVI research farm, has conducted some of the most long-standing and worthy sheep and beef research projects over decades.

“That has benefited the industry hugely and farmers, agriculture and red meat in general will suffer by not having that investment from the state purse, but also co-invested research and development – whether that is private or levy-funded organisations to work the state government to put the nutrient back in the paddock.”

Deliberate ‘death by a thousand cuts’

Mr Leeming said he hoped farmers would be given an opportunity to consult with the Victorian Government on any proposed RDAE staff changes.

“There has been a deliberate death by a thousand cuts in this space,” he said.

“The PVI research farm in Hamilton used to be one of the biggest employers at Hamilton 20 years ago and the offices are empty now, rather than full; it’s like a ghost town in there.”

Mr Leeming said the $3.5 million Red Meat Innovation Centre at Hamilton opened five years ago “hasn’t fired a shot from a producer’s point of view.”

“What a waste of money that is and I thought it was going to be rejuvenated.

“With the rise of sheep meat exports in the last five years and the massive contribution it is making to the state purse, we were very excited when that red meat centre was opened,” Mr Leeming said.

“We are in a good paddock and good paddocks need to be fertilised.

“And south-west Victoria is a super-important good paddock that needs to be well-fertilised.”

Mr Leeming said he would be taking up the issue with the other SAMRC regional committees, and the State Government-run BestWool BestLamb and BetterBeef networks.

Agriculture Victoria employs more than 1100 people across 50 sites throughout regional and metropolitan Victoria.



Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your comment will not appear until it has been moderated.
Contributions that contravene our Comments Policy will not be published.


  1. Murray Gregory, November 14, 2019

    Isn’t ‘research that doesn’t attract co-investment’ precisely the sort of research that government would want to undertake? Co-investment implies financial benefit for a commercial party.

    Historically, all truly ground-breaking research has been done by scientists answering enigmatic questions – for the sake of it. Then consider the on-selling of the commercial rights – a higher stakes game with potentially much higher returns.

Get Sheep Central's news headlines emailed to you -