Recruitment: How to give (and take) constructive criticism in the workplace

Sheep Central, February 2, 2018

Latest listings on our Jobs Central recruitment page:

  • Livestock Manager – Victorian Livestock Exchange
  • AHA-Exec Mgr, Emergency Preparedness/Response-(via Carnovale)
  • Purchasing Officer-protein procurement and supply chain company
  • Livestock Administration Assistant (Carrington Group)
  • Industry Leadership Manager (Sheep Producers Australia)
  • Senior Head Stockperson – Nockatunga (CPC)
  • General Farm Hand (Thomas Foods International)
  • Stationhand – NSW (Strathbogie Pastoral)
  • Marketing and Communications Manager (Australian Wagyu Association)
  • Mill Operator (Performance Feeds)
  • Grain Fed Operations Assistant Analyst (JBS)
  • General Manager – Regional QLD (Rimfire Resources grains client)

Click here to access these and other exciting meat and livestock supply chain positions currently listed on Jobs Central.


IF you’re a manager, supervisor, team leader or any type of boss working in the sheepmeat or wool industry, there will be times when you will have to give feedback to employees.

Sometimes it will be positive and sometimes not, so you might like to consider how it is delivered.

Here are a few tips to assist when giving constructive criticism.

Be Specific
You need to ensure you tell the staffmember exactly what requires improvement. Just saying ‘that work outcome was rubbish’ is not going to help. You’ll be more help if you are specific and use suggestions such as ‘I’ve always found that this approach produces a good outcome’.

Don’t get personal and be polite
Everyone is busy and stressed, but racing in and saying “I hate the way you did this” is not the best way to communicate feedback. Think about how you would feel if someone said that to you. Ensure you talk about the work and not the person. Be tactful, and respectful.

A simple approach to use when you need to give constructive criticism so that an employee can improve is ‘PIP’, or Positive Improvement Positive. It includes these three simple steps:

  • Take time to consider what you like about what they done, and communicate that to them first
  • Next, give feedback on what can be improved and offer suggestions
  • Lastly, at the end of the conversation ensure you restate the positive aspects of their work again

Thinking from your employees’ point of view, at least they will know that it’s only certain aspects they need to improve upon and they won’t be left on an outright low.

Giving constructive criticism isn’t just one communication. Ensure you follow up and give praise where praise is due. This will be a great way to acknowledge your employee’s improvement.

How to take constructive criticism

Firstly, stop – don’t say anything. Give yourself time to think about what is being said and don’t react defensively.

It is easy to be hurt or take things personally, but in the main, constructive criticism is given so you can make positive change. Put it in context, it’s about your work and not you as a person. Own it and accept that no one is perfect.

Make sure your superior has been specific, so you know what you need to work on. You might want to take notes, so your boss knows you are listening. Ensure you are clear on the feedback and you may need to ask questions or ask for suggestions. Initiate a follow up with your boss to see if you are on track when you have improved your work.

Giving or taking constructive criticism doesn’t need to be such a negative experience, if both parties understand each other’s perspective and it is given with good intention.

The last word – If you are just a work colleague, don’t offer constructive criticism unless you have been asked for your help by your fellow staffer, or you sense they are open to suggestions. It may be a role you have filled previously.






Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your comment will not appear until it has been moderated.
Contributions that contravene our Comments Policy will not be published.


Get Sheep Central's news headlines emailed to you -