Lamb Production

Petition seeks mandatory sheep pain relief for mulesing

Terry Sim, May 13, 2019

Professor Peter Windsor explaining mulesing to German documentary maker Joanna Michna during the 2018 documentary.

A GERMAN filmmaker has launched a petition calling for mandatory use of pain relief for mulesing and other operations, and government intervention to phase out the flystrike prevention practice in Australia.

German filmmaker Joanna Michna. Image – ZDFzoom.

The filmmaker, Joanna Michna and her film crew have launched German and English versions of the petition on www.change.org after completing a documentary on sheep welfare in Australia last year.

The petition has received more than 38,000 signatures since it was launched online in German on May 1 and within the first 10 days gained 31,343 supporters on change.org plus another 4082 on Avaaz. The English language version was released on change.org on May 10.

The petitioners are proposing to present the petition and signatures to the new Australian Government after the May 18 federal election.

Ms Michna said the petition will be online till the end of July and the organisers plan to hand it over no sooner than September this year. She said petition is not asking for a ban of mulesing.

“It´s aimed to ban surgical interventions on sheep without pain relief, including mulesing, and to reinforce breeding programs with the goal to phase out mulesing eventually when it is safe for the sheep to do so.”

Ms Michna said the idea to the petition was born because of the number of emails she received in reaction to the documentary made in Australia last year.

The SPIEGEL TV documentary for German station ZDF called ‘The true price of cuddly wool’ — filmed last year and broadcast in February this year — included interviews with international designers and retailers, Australian growers, brokers and researchers, and former Australian Wool Innovation chairman Wal Merriman — about wool traceability, mulesing and animal welfare issues. The documentary and an associated but independently written Der SPIEGEL magazine article created concern among European processors and in Australia about the portrayal of wool welfare and sheep management practices. Germany is the 12 largest direct importer of raw Australian wool and is a major importer of woollen garments from China and other countries.

“Normally you research a subject, delve into it as deeply as possible, bring it to life during production and post, and when it is aired – it is “born” and takes on it´s own life with its audience,” Ms Michna said.

“But this time I really felt I couldn’t quite let go with the incredible feedback I got from all sides.

“So we – as the film crew team – decided to launch the petition to voice our concerns and hopes of how wool should be produced and the welfare of sheep be increased.”

Ms Michna said the petition is supported by Four Paws (Vier Pfoten) Germany, PETA Germany and the VERBRAUCHER INITIATIVE e.V, an independent German consumer protection initiative.

Ms Michna said would also start contacting labels and stores selling Merino wool to inform them of the petition´s progress.

“In our digitalized world, where petition support mails pop up every few minutes in your cells, we feel it is an important message about what is important to consumers and what people feel comfortable with in regards to how we treat animals.

“We strongly hope this message will as well be heard by the Australian politicians and wool industry,” she said.

The petition’s preamble says “the Australian government must oblige the wool industry to set a new time frame to phase out the practice of mulesing, since in the long term there is only one solution: Merino sheep must be bred, which are less wrinkled and have less wool growth in the tail area.”

“A new government will be elected in May 2019.

“If we get thousands of signatures, we can hand this petition over to the key ministers of agriculture in Australia in the presence of national and international press and put the pressure right on,” the preamble says.

WoolProducers sounds warning on community expectations

Peak grower body WoolProducers Australia supports the mandatory use of pain relief for mulesing, but not the banning of the practice.

“Mulesing is undertaken with the long-term welfare of sheep in mind and remains the most effective breech flystrike prevention practice in Australian sheep industries,” WPA chief executive officer Jo Hall said.

“An alternative practice that prevents breech flystrike as effectively as mulesing is yet to be found.

“With this in mind to maintain the legal right to mules, it is in the interests of most wool growers that pain relief must be administered when mulesing as we are strongly opposed to the setting of another mulesing ban deadline,” she said.

“In many circumstances, mulesing with pain relief is the highest standard of animal welfare that can be provided to sheep for breech strike prevention.

“Industry must keep abreast of community expectations to retain farming practices to ensure negative or adverse public sentiments do not force government to intervene with legislative actions, such as banning mulesing,” Ms Hall said.

New Zealand has already banned mulesing, but current Minister for Agriculture David Littleproud has said a Coalition Government would not ban the practice.

Click here to read the English language version of the petition and more information can be found on Facebook #nopain4sheep. The German language versions of the petition can be seen on change.org and at avaaz.org .

HAVE YOUR SAY

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your comment will not appear until it has been moderated.
Contributions that contravene our Comments Policy will not be published.

Comments

  1. Sienna Martz, May 14, 2019

    Mulesing is a barbaric and violent procedure that must be banned.

  2. John Buxton, May 13, 2019

    They who call for a ban on mulesing have no social licence.

  3. Doug Wright, May 13, 2019

    A solution to mulesing is available. The SRS breeding system developed 30 years ago by the late Jim Watts is the answer; not only is there no need to mules, but it eliminates body strike, so no jetting is needed. In addition these sheep are highly fertile and are capable of high weaning rates.

  4. Jim Gordon, May 13, 2019

    Terry, thank you for a very interesting and informative article.

  5. John Smith, May 13, 2019

    Here’s a news flash Jo Hall: Since 1988, the late Dr Jim Watts has developed an alternative way of effectively preventing breech and body flystrike in Merino sheep. It is done using his SRS breeding principles. Please do your homework, you will be amazed at how productive and easy care these Merinos are.

Get Sheep Central's news headlines emailed to you -
FREE!