Markets

Does President Trump need an ‘off ramp’ on lamb tariffs?

Terry Sim November 16, 2026

Donald Trump faces increased scrutiny on his tariff policies after his Republican Party lost control of Congress and US trade commissioners became divided over the impact of lamb imports.

 

HAS American president Donald Trump been gifted a tariff policy ‘off-ramp’ by the United States International Trade Commission’s split decision on whether lamb imports had injured or were a threat of injury to America’s domestic industry?

Research fellow with the University of Sydney’s US Studies Centre economic security program Robert Monterosso thinks so.

The American sheep industry has welcomed the USITC decision last week as the first step to relief from Australian and New Zealand lamb imports, while Australia’s meat processors and sheep producers are also encouraged by the vote.

The split vote by the USITC commissioners follows hard on the Democrats regaining control of the US Congress, which has increased their ability to question Mr Trump’s pro-tariff activities.

USSC research fellow Robert Monterosso.

However, on the question of whether the split USITC decision might make it harder for President Trump and the US lamb industry to implement some import relief action, Mr Monterosso said it always difficult to predict what the president will do on tariffs.

“The split decision does give the president an off-ramp, which he might favour as his tariff policy becomes increasingly unpopular with US voters.

“The split decision is good for Aussie industry, but the Australian Government must continue to bat for the industry and engage with the administration on this issue,” he said.

Mr Monterosso said the split decision will give newly elected Democrats extra ammunition in their campaign against tariffs, “but the decision ultimately lies with President Trump.”

The next USITC public hearing on remedy is on December 1, 2026, and its report — containing determinations, remedy recommendations, certain additional findings, and the basis for them — will go to the president by January 11, 2027.

“It’s unlikely that President Trump will try to rush through an increase in tariff or import quotas before new Democrats senators and congress people are sworn in in January,” Mr Monterosso said.

He said the Trump administration would be conscious that the Republicans lost mid-term elections on cost-of-living “and may be hesitant to add fuel to that fire.”

“It might be too early to tell, but the results of the mid-terms have increased scrutiny on the administration’s tariff policy.

“Any protectionist actions will need to be connected to the findings of the USITC investigation,” he said.

US 30pc import tariff bill likely ‘dead in the water’

After US Democrats took back control of the country’s Congress in the mid-term elections on 3 November, Mr Monterosso said they will oppose the US bill H.R.7276 to impose a 30pc duty on sheep/lamb imports.

“Many Democrats won on a platform of tackling cost-of-living expenses and rising grocery bills. Opposing this bill would fit in with that campaign.

“Importantly, because the Democrats now have the power to set the legislative agenda, they can also choose not to bring a bill like this to the floor,” he said.

“Given this, the bill is likely dead in the water.”

Mr Monterosso said Democrat leaders generally oppose President Trump’s tariff policy.

“They will make efforts to roll back many tariffs as a way of achieving cost-of-living relief.

“However, any Congressional bill seeking to undo tariffs could face an immediate personal veto from President Trump,” he said.

“The Democrats can set up congressional hearings and investigations into existing tariff policies to compel US Government officials to present evidence, which could potentially lead to federal court challenges to tariffs.

“But this process could take several months if not years,” Mr Monterosso said.

“While new tariffs are unlikely to pass, any tariffs that have already passed the Congress will be difficult to roll back as long as President Trump remains in office.”

Mr Monterosso said President Trump can still use his executive power to levy temporary tariffs or import quotas for up to 150 days under Section 122 of the Trade Act, although this is unlikely.

“Other options, such as Section 232 or Section 301 would require investigations from the US Trade Representative.”

Mr Monterosso said Congress cannot block or override a presidential remedy if the USITC Section 201 investigation into lamb imports finds that these imports caused serious industry harm.

“However, the Democrat-controlled Congress can hold oversight hearings and compel US Government officials to present evidence to support the decision.

“If the evidence isn’t satisfactory, it could get challenged in a federal court.”

Mr Monterosso believes the Australian Government should work with industry to present President Trump an “off-ramp” that does not include tariffs or import quotas on Australian product.

“A lamb import checkoff could be that off-ramp, although it could require amendments to federal laws and USDA review.

“A lamb checkoff may not fix the inherent demand issues in the US lamb industry – US consumption of lamb is simply too low to justify any significant domestic production.”

 

HAVE YOUR SAY

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your comment will not appear until it has been moderated.
Contributions that contravene our Comments Policy will not be published.

Comments

Get Sheep Central's news headlines emailed to you -
FREE!