Wool Production

AWI Review of Performance recommends BNC changes

Sheep Central November 16, 2026

 

AUSTRALIAN Wool Innovation’s board has committed to implement all recommendations from its latest independent review of performance, including changes to its board nomination committee structure.

AWI said the review covered the four-year period to 2025 and acknowledged the improvements made across AWI’s operations, while also recommending areas for further improvement.

The review found that some AWI board committees – People & Culture, and Research & Development — “exercised a degree of oversight that extends beyond governance oversight into operational decision-making and management processes.”

This included involvement in recruitment and people management matters below CEO level, together with detailed and ongoing scrutiny of individual RD&E and marketing investments.

“While providing the board with strong visibility over operational activities, these practices may indicate that elements of the governance framework are insufficiently differentiated from management functions, potentially limiting management autonomy and diverting committee and board attention from strategic oversight, organisational performance and risk governance.

“Linked to this observation is a finding that the composition of the board has not served AWI as well as it could during the period,” the review found.

The review found that board skills matrix and director recruitment approach are heavily weighted towards industry knowledge and sector experience, with less emphasis on skills aligned to the board’s governance responsibilities, including strategic oversight, enterprise risk management, portfolio governance, investment oversight, project assurance and contract governance.

“The board’s composition differs from contemporary governance benchmarks, which generally require majority of directors to be independent.

“While the current composition provides strong industry representation and stakeholder legitimacy, the proportion of directors that could be regarded as independent in substance under contemporary governance definitions is lower than would typically be expected under leading governance practice.”

The review found there is no predetermined mechanism for resolving situations where directors have equal tenure.

“Formalising this process would provide greater certainty for directors and shareholders, reduce reliance on discretionary decision-making, and improve transparency regarding board succession arrangements.”

The review found that perceptions that the independence of the Board Nominations Committee (BNC) is removed by the order by which independent members are recruited to the committee and that the overall process is perceived to lack transparency and equity by stakeholders.”

To strengthen stakeholder confidence in the transparency and objectivity of future director selection arrangements, the review recommended that the BNC Charter be updated to reflect that:

  • any previous directors are excluded from serving as a member of the Board Nomination Committee until at least two election cycles have passed.
  • Candidates are nominated by the BNC with reference to the refreshed board skills matrix
  • The process to determine director retirement and re-election sequencing is through a documented rotation framework with pre-determined criteria.

The review received feedback that the nominations and election process for AWI board directors deters interest of well skilled candidates and of repeat interest in a future nomination process and election.

“It was; however, also noted in our review that recent renewal of the board and the recruitment of CEO from outside of the wool industry, together with uplifts in governance documentation and artefacts and the impact of previous changes to governance, is expected to translate to improved governance in practice over time.

“It is also recognised that the body of work completed by staff in uplifting governance documentation and artefacts has been substantial during a time of contracting budgets so that more time to embed the uplifts systematically and consistently is warranted.”

AWI said the review by GHD has recognised the significant progress made by the organisation and the stronger foundation now in place to support its future.

A spokesman said AWI has committed to implementing all recommendations arising from the review as part of its ongoing commitment to continuous improvement, transparency and delivering value to the Australian wool industry.

ROP report released day before AGM

Although the final GHD report was delivered to the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry and reviewed by  the AWI board in September this year, it was only publicly released a day before the 2026 annual general meeting, which was held as a virtual meeting on 13 November. Neither AWI chairman George Millington nor chief executive officer Bryan Fry mentioned the report or its findings during the AGM.

“The chairman and CEO presented on matters relevant to the 25/26 Annual Report,” the spokesman said.

The AWI spokesman denied that the ROP report was deliberately released late by AWI, on the day before the AGM, to limit the chances for any questions from AWI shareholders.

“Not at all.

“It was released as soon as was practical after meeting DAFF to discuss the report and discuss our work to respond to the recommendations.”

Only 62 people attended the virtual AGM and there were no questions from shareholders.

Implement BNC recommendations before next election

New South Wales wool grower Michael Field said he believed there were a lot of “unnecessary committees on AWI (with board members) doing unnecessary things.”

“The board is there to oversee the running of the company and not get into the nitty gritty of it.”

Mr Field believed the AWI board nomination committee should exclude former and retiring directors to avoid potential conflicts of interest.

“I do have a problem when you have two retiring directors being on the BNC.

“It’s got to be a skills-based board to suit the running of the business.”

But he said there should be one current board member on the BNC.

Mr Field said he also supported AWI having a five-year corporate strategy and ideally aligned with Meat & Livestock Australia.

He believed the ROP’s recommendations on the BNC need to be implemented before the next AWI board election in November 2027.

Click here to read the full review of performance report.

 

HAVE YOUR SAY

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your comment will not appear until it has been moderated.
Contributions that contravene our Comments Policy will not be published.

Comments

Get Sheep Central's news headlines emailed to you -
FREE!